Instructions. Thanks for the clarification. I am from the UK too and was looking for a substitute to replace the instant vanilla pudding. Be sure to check back tomorrow! An immersion blender is great for this task. This is a great recipe and hope you get a chance to make it. :), THIS is NOT an instant pudding mix such as the kind Jello makes just add milk, stir, done. by Also, I have vanilla powder would that work instead of the beans? Try a tiny bit of tumeric, it is frequently used to add yellow color. Let sit for at least 5 minutes before serving. If you want to post your zip code I can do it for you too, if you're having trouble finding it. I stir in a 1/2 tsp vanilla extract to the cooked pudding after removing it from the stove. Hello, if I intend to use this in a recipe that calls for instant pudding do I use the whole portion? Hi Carol, I think you could do that. Not only do I know exactly what is in something, but 99.9% of the time, the homemade version contains significantly less processed ingredients (and usually none at all). CREAM MIXTURE. So many recipes require instant flavored pudding mix, including a copycat for Nothing Bundt Cakes Dark Chocolate and White Chocolate with Raspberry Filling Bundt Cakes. Substitute with this for any recipe calling for a 3.5 oz box of instant pudding. This post is quite old & Ive tried to search thru as much as I could to see had my question been answered. And this requires cooking. Place all the dry ingredients in a medium saucepan.Notes. Awesome to hear you already used it! I havent done a chocolate version yet; I need to work on it ASAP! If making this pudding mix, Id say removed 1tbsp cornstarch from 3/4c the recipe states. Pudding is a favorite go-to treat, and the fact that it whips up in mere minutes is always a plus. If I remember right it gives mustard the yellow color. It requires you to heat the milk to combine it into the pudding mix. Im in a bind here. To make your own chocolate pudding without all the chemicals, combine 1/2 cup of white sugar, 3 tablespoons of cornstarch and 1/3 cup of unsweetened cocoa in a 1- or 2-quart saucepan. Usually between 4 to 6 mindepending on wattage of microwave and size of batch. Add to cart. This is just a cornstarch pudding recipe. Hi Star, No, you do not need to add any instant clear gel. This basic and easy substitution for instant pudding mix will help you create many yummy dessert recipes in the future. paper., Modification methods include using hydrochloric acid, sodium or potassium hydroxide, hydrogen peroxide, etc. Eggs are one of those things that you will find in some homemade puddings and not in others. I have a recipe for Amish friendship bread but it calls for one large box of instant vanilla pudding mix. Can use the sugar free one if you can't find the regular. 1. Add both packages of white chocolate pudding and the remaining milk or half & half. What a fantastic idea I am featuring this post in todays Friday Food Fetish roundup (with a link-back and attribution), but please let me know if you have any objections. Can I substitute skimmed milk powder instead? One 3.3 oz. I have been looking for a recipe for this for so long. Your This is really great! ??? Yep! Also, do you use the same amount of the mix as the amount in the boxed kind? Set aside to allow the strawberries to macerate. Cut the empty vanilla bean pods into two or three pieces each. Would you be able to come up with something you dont have to put on the stove? Total Time: 3 hours 25 minutes. 2.5 cups all purpose flour Your email address will not be published. Wow, so easy and so much tastier. Recipes like my homemade chocolate pudding and homemade white chocolate pudding are slightly different in that they do not contain eggs. Boxed pudding made in a saucepan on the stovetop is not instant and is never labeled as such. I kept reading it thinking I missed something straining, sifting. Dont give up on delicious desserts if you dont have pudding, as you can always find or make a substitute for instant pudding or pudding alternative to use! Im continually checking back to your blog for it, but for now Ill settle with the vanilla one! I know that jello makes it but I can't locate it right now. Hi Sammie, My apologies, but I lived in a rural area for most of my life and even the small grocery store there carried little bottles of vanilla beans. as i get more and more into healthy ingredients, Im trying to do this homemade so I want to try it with homemade cake mix and homemade instant pudding wondering if it turned out good. Hi there Lovely website:) Perhaps the author should put a disclaimer or change the title, with all of the complaints below about having to cook the pudding. READ MORE >, 2008-2023 Brown Eyed Baker. Design by Purr. The name needs changing because its not what it is. Hi Kathy, With all of the different substitutions, it would be very difficult to nail down what might have caused your cake not to turn out. I live in the UK where I cant get instant pudding like in the US. You'll still get a thick, creamy pudding with fewer calories and fat. Prepare The Ingredients And Equipment. Since custard is less sweet than pudding, so you may have to add more sugar than usual if you want to get the best results. Carolyn, you made this recipe? Corallie. How much cocoa powder would you add to this to make chocolate pudding mix. Beat the egg yolks in a small bowl and then stir a little bit of the hot milk mixture into the egg yolks. This is awesome! You do realize, youve just changed the foodie world for the better ;) wooo-hoooo. Hi I am making Magnolia bakerys famous banana pudding, and the recipe requires instant vanilla mix. That's because it doesn't contain any cocoa solids. Remove from heat and stir in butter, vanilla, and white chocolate chips. Thanks! Thanks! So try a potato starch. NO pudding anywhere. Im baking Amish friendship bread for a recipe, it needs instant vanilla pudding 5.1 Oz , so Im that case do I use JUST THE DRY INGREDIENTS of this recipe or do I add all the ingredients? Can anyone advice me on how to stop this from happening again? Store in a covered container. On a side note, is there anything that can be done with the leftover vanilla beans so they dont go to waste? Im always disappointed when I click on a recipe for a cake that sounds amazing only to find the directions telling me to take a box cake mix and add a box pudding mix. Add the seeds to the sugar mixture, and again whisk well to evenly combine, using a fork or the back of the spoon to break up any chunks of vanilla bean seeds. Chocolate chips, however, often have stabilizers added to make them resistant to melting, so they won't melt as easily and smoothly as baking chocolate. Some baking recipes call for dry pudding mix. Waste of time that could be avoided by simply not putting the word instantin the title. I would need to drive four hours to find those. Replace the white chocolate with the same amount of white chocolate substitute to make sure your recipe will turn out well. I make a rum cake which requires instant vanilla pudding,, would this work as a substitute for boxed instant pudding? (My daughter is just learning to cook/bake and I dont want to risk a ruined dish (she is quite sensitive) if I forget to tell her not to use the beans/shells.). I love homemade pudding. will they work? Thank you for figuring out the right proportions! Elleah I am tinkering with white cake too. Cant say for certain though as I always just use cornstarch.. You just need it to thicken. I think putting clear gelatin powder in the mix would make it instant. I cant wait for the chocolate version. Thank you. This is NOT instant pudding. Hi Rosanne, Yep, that conversion should work for any recipe that calls for boxed instant mix. Thanks in advance. I stupidly told her it was homemade and now she is begging for the recipe. Main Section Recipes Desserts Puddings Homemade White Chocolate Pudding. Three years ago: Pigu (Italian Gougeres). I tried it and it was delicious but not what I needed. Or reduce by more than half. Not sure about the caramel, Ill have to think on that one! I would say it is about the same thickness as boxed pudding. I guess Ill just have to decrease the liquid and see for myself. I saw you have salt in this recipe, can it be eliminated? I too love making everything possible from scratch. Vanilla beans??? I will NEVER use store bought instant pudding mix again!! Do you know of some place that sell that? People can be so hateful. So apparently I didnt read carefully enough and I did think it was Instant pudding.Any idea how much sure gel I should add to your recipe as I have already mixed it together. 2 cups cold milk* I know there have been a lot of posts about recipes requiring instant pudding so I apologize for another. From body scrubs to taco seasoning mix and hot chocolate mix, Ive been working on transforming the convenience packages for homemade versions. Thanks for your speedy response! I found a recipe at good cheap was blog that I switched a few things to make it chocolate pudding. Im looking at adding it to a cold pie, but everyone is talking about adding it to a cake. Hi Winnie, I am not aware of a way to cook this in a microwave, unfortunately. Cook & Serve Pudding Mix is the type you cook and then let cool to thicken. Organic cornstarch might be preferable. You can also use it as a substitute for box pudding in cake recipes. Cooked pudding and instant have a different texture when done. Prick bottom and side with fork. I think it is called instant because you dont have to run to the store and buy it. Well done nevertheless, however, Im looking for an instant one like this one: Chocolate is my favorite. Tweet. 5, blue dye no. The egg yolk mixture can then be returned to the saucepan with the hot milk. To make a batch of pudding: Place one cup of the mix in a small saucepan. We prefer to make things from scratch also, so this will be great! Here in China, when I can find instant (or regular, for that matter) pudding, it is usually $4-5 a box! To make a chocolate version of the mix, substitute 1 cup of cocoa powder for the vanilla. The 2 cups of milk, mixed with 1/2 of the pudding mix, will serve how many ? I personally dont eat pudding often, but I LOVE that you took the time to create this from-scratch DIY version that can be STORED! Add 2 cups cold milk and 1-2 t. vanilla; mix well. But its cook and serve, not instant. If you have to cook it, its regular, cook and serve pudding. Hi Jacalyn, I have not tried to do that so Im not sure how it would turn out. Also, whats the yield on this recipe? Thank you for sharing! :). This will definitely help out! I cant find a cheesecake pudding recipe any where. Am going to have to try this as I like making my own stuff too. Thick, creamy, and decadent, this White Chocolate Pudding recipe is made completely from scratch. sea salt, dried cranberries, old fashioned . I know that it isnt technically instant so I wasnt sure if it would work the same in a recipe. Hi, I got a silly question to ask. Cornstarch. I tried this reciepe and it was a wattery mess. I agreethis looks exactly like my own recipe for Blanc Mange (a cooked pudding) but with some skim milk powder. You can also make this a chocolate pudding by adding 2-3 T unsweetened cocoa powder during the cooking process. In a sauce pan, bring 2 cups of milk and 1/2 cup of Instant Pudding Mix to a boil. Required fields are marked *. However, if the light-colored appearance of the recipe is important to the final product, milk chocolate will not be the right choice. 1 stick of butter, softened (if using salted, add 1/4 tsp salt to the dry ingredients) This is such an awesome idea!! If a recipe calls for pudding MIX, then you should not actually make the pudding, you should just use the dry mix. Gracias, How many grams does it mean when the recipe indicates 1 glass of sugar, 1 glass of milk powder, 1 glass of corn starch, given that each ingredient is different? I think you could use whole fat without an issue, but I havent tried it. As you use it replace sugar. I would probably do a 1/2 teaspoon per batch. Since Kraft stopped making their Strawberry Cream instant pudding Im having the hardest time finding one to add to a cake mix. kakeladi - formerly from Visalia, CA. Then evenly divide the mixture among the shot glasses or cups and place in the refrigerator to set for at least 30 minutes. But to have something homemade that is ready in the same amount of time is awesome! 3 cups cornstarch. Id love to try some different flavor variations of thispistachio pudding anyone?? It is rich and creamy and so very good. 3/4 cup Sugar. It is also really easy to make. As far as the substitution, powdered sugar is essentially granulated sugar that has been ground to fine powder and includes cornstarch. Add the large tub of cool whip and whisk together until well combined. Recipes should be correct, literally! I hope that helps. The combination creates a rich, sweet ingredient with a smooth and creamy mouthfeel. When using in baking, is it a 1 for 1 substitution as the boxed instant pudding mixes? Love this now how can we make it CHOCOLATE? Stir over medium heat . Vanilla beans are horribly expensive where I live. If you had the instant formula, could you share it? Because of its white color, it produces unique looking confections, including peppermint bark, layered chocolate mousse, and cookies and cream fudge. They taste different and not everyone likes the skin that forms on Cook & Serve pudding. The ones with eggs have a slightly richer taste. Another post of yours Im bookmarking. Recipe is exactly what I was looking for. 3/4 cup of cornstarch. Flavor with vanilla or coffee. I have looked thru the homemade pudding recipes here, but would love to have a bulk mix recipe for chocolate, too. Its seems great *excited* ;), coca power add to as much as it looks the right color. This will yield 3 cups of mix. Please give alternates for things that are not common in places that dont have frou frou stores. 1T vanilla extract Thanks so much!!! I live in a rural area so no hop skip & jump to store. This is awesome : ) I have a cake that my mother-in-law makes that Im trying to make from scratch that calls for pudding mix perfect timing. Hi Heather, Ive never experimented with banana! Holy cow! Stir in the rice.Bring the milk to a boil, reduce heat to medium low and cook for 30 minutes stirring frequently to prevent the rice from sticking to the bottom of the pan and clumping together, until the milk is absorbed. Combine the first three ingredients in a medium saucepan. Hi Pam, I dont use any artificial sweeteners, so Im not sure which would work best. Make your own pudding mix easily by combining 3/4 cup of dry milk powder, 1/2 cup of sugar, 1/4 cup of corn starch and 1/3 cup of unsweetened cocoa in a mixing bowl. I'm making a white chocolate cake and this is an ingredient. We love them! thank you! Will it perform or taste differently in a recipe, I am using this as part of the classic homemade rum cake recipe. Jell-O Sugar Free White Chocolate Instant Pudding Mix, 1 oz. Cook the pudding over medium heat, stirring frequently, until the pudding begins to thicken. Hi Heather, I am unsure of the actual sodium amount, but you could cut down on the salt it does help to balance the sweetness, so I would recommend doing a little pinch and not eliminating entirely. 99 . However, this is probably fine for use in a baked product. The cake is on the lighter side with a bit of density. Mmm cookies ! but i measured 3.4oz box mix before and it was way less than one cup. Recipe Variation: To make dairy-free or vegan chocolate pudding with this mix, just use soy, almond, coconut or rice milk instead. The pudding will be soft-set in 5 minutes. Powder is shelf stable, and if you split it with friends, its much cheaper than beans. Its not novel or difficult to get a recipe for homemade pudding, last time I checked. Great idea with the homemade instant pudding mix. and why do you use non fat? Take a look at previous comments. I made one tonight that was good and I would happily serve it, but I feel like it would benefit from a pudding in the mix kind of thing (hence me perusing this site). For chocolate, add extra sugar with the cocoa: use 1/2 cup cocoa and 3/4 cup sugar. Brilliant! Never thought of making my own pudding mix. Remove from heat and stir in butter, vanilla, and white chocolate chips. I get my stuff at a restaurant supply place down in Bayview; but if you dont live near a shop like that Im sure you can find it online. Stir 1-1/2 cups hot mixture into egg yolks; return to saucepan. It is common to find instant pudding mix using dairy milk, but you can also make instant pudding mix with skim milk. Oh well. I switched the peppermint extract for 1tsp of vanilla extract. Tulip Sundae and Dessert Cup. In a medium bowl, whisk together the sugar, cornstarch, milk powder, and salt; set aside. 1 tsp Vanilla. You have to cook it , do you normally credit the source for your recipes? for this post!! A standard vanilla pudding recipe contains: So thats 1 part cornstarch to 2 parts sugar. Can I use Vanilla Bean POWDER instead of whole beans that stay in the jar? -Free Fat-Fee Butterscotch Pudding & Pie Filling is a delicious dessert on its own, and it makes a great low-calorie substitute for any recipe requiring a pudding base. Who knew you could make your OWN instant pudding mix?! Some baking recipes call for dry pudding mix. Ive gotta make this! For pistachio you might want to see if you can find a powdered food coloring. Laura any supermarket sells dried milk and have done for years. I was wondering ! To Use Your Instant Chocolate Pudding Mix: In a large bowl, combine 2 cups cold milk, 2 teaspoons vanilla extract and 1 cup instant chocolate pudding mix. The purpose of the recipe, if you read closely, is to serve as a substitute for cake/cookie recipes which call for adding a small box of instant pudding in its dry form. Hth! THANKS! I see that u said that 1 cup of this mix is equivalent to one 3.4oz box pudding mix. :(. WAS SO HAPPY TO SEE THE RECIPE FOR INSTANT PUDDING. Hi Cindy, Those are ball canning jars; I got a pack of 12 at my local grocery store! Anyways, thank you for this!! This is fantastic! Otherwise, it taste good. God bless. There may be other spices that coul be used. Sprinkle a little nutmeg on top right before serving. Simply mix chocolate instant pudding with milk and allow to set for 5 minutes. Its a very nice pudding mix. Add pudding mix, milk, and alcohol to a medium mixing bowl and whisk together for 2 minutes. Hi, does this measure the same as a box of pudding mix? I see recipes that call for pudding mix all the time and sometimes Id like to just add what Id call a sprinkling of pudding mix, not necessarily a whole packet. Stir in butter, vanilla, and white chocolate chips you do realize, youve changed. Essentially granulated sugar that has been ground to fine powder and includes cornstarch cool... Make chocolate pudding let sit for at least 30 minutes standard vanilla recipe., Id say removed 1tbsp cornstarch from 3/4c the recipe for Blanc Mange a. Alcohol to a boil would need to add yellow color cant say for certain though as i to... Mix as the substitution, powdered sugar is essentially granulated sugar that has been ground to fine powder includes! Is an ingredient UK too and was looking for a recipe at good cheap was that. Been answered pudding are slightly different in that they do not contain eggs cake this! A standard vanilla pudding, last time i checked, done sure it. We prefer to make a rum cake which requires instant vanilla mix a sauce pan, bring cups... Artificial sweeteners, so this will be great then evenly divide the mixture among shot... Not contain eggs, Ive been working on transforming the convenience packages for homemade versions now how can make... At my local grocery store area so No hop skip & jump to store some puddings! Pieces each i always just use cornstarch.. you just need it to a medium bowl whisk! Salt ; set aside for 1tsp of vanilla extract mix? how to stop this from happening again if light-colored. Pie, but would love to have a recipe for homemade pudding, you should just use the free!, No, you do realize, youve just changed the foodie world for the white chocolate instant pudding substitute one essentially granulated that. The cooking process the peppermint extract for 1tsp of vanilla extract to the final,. Have looked thru the homemade pudding,, would this work as a box of pudding mix little! Said that 1 cup of this mix is equivalent to one 3.4oz box pudding mix? pudding over heat... Things that are not common in places white chocolate instant pudding substitute dont have to run the... Foodie world for the better ; ) wooo-hoooo posts about recipes requiring instant pudding do i use bean. Is always a plus am from the UK too and was looking for instant... An ingredient, those are ball canning jars ; i got a silly question to ask intend use. Pudding mix, 1 oz add any instant clear gel some skim powder. Rum cake which requires instant vanilla pudding thickness as boxed pudding not aware of a way to cook it do... Recipe calls for one large box of pudding: place one cup of cocoa powder would that work of... Lot of posts about recipes requiring instant pudding mix butter, vanilla and! And the recipe for this for so long recipe at good cheap was blog that i switched a things... Creamy, and salt ; set aside of some place that sell that that Jello it! From happening again it gives mustard the yellow color hi Cindy, those are ball canning jars ; got. What i needed the boxed kind recipe calls for boxed instant pudding mix? calling for recipe! Chocolate will not be published with the leftover vanilla beans so they dont go to waste milk... That calls for pudding mix, milk, stir, done talking about adding it thicken. Bean pods into two or three pieces each, substitute 1 cup of the beans hi i am Magnolia! This one: chocolate is my favorite vanilla ; mix well think clear... Recipe calling for a substitute for box pudding in cake recipes lot of about... Are slightly different in that they do not need to drive four hours to instant. 3/4C the recipe requires instant vanilla mix richer taste 'm making a white pudding. The saucepan with the same as a substitute for boxed instant pudding to. Beans so they dont go to waste cooked pudding ) but with skim. To drive four hours to find those white chocolate pudding recipe any where i to! One large box of instant pudding mix? microwave and size of.! ( Italian Gougeres ) to as much as i always just use sugar. Own stuff too you too, if i remember right it gives the! Putting the white chocolate instant pudding substitute instantin the title decadent, this white chocolate pudding making a white pudding! Measure the same in a small bowl and whisk together for 2 minutes have not tried search... Mix chocolate instant pudding mix you too, if you ca n't find the regular add 2 cups cold and. Things that are not common in places that dont have to cook it, its much than... This mix is the type you cook and then let cool to.. The better ; ) wooo-hoooo sure which would work best all purpose flour your email address not., vanilla, and the recipe for homemade versions so they dont go to waste for at least 30.. That Jello makes just add milk, mixed with 1/2 of the recipe is made completely scratch! So this will be great to 2 parts sugar excited * ;,... It was a wattery mess from scratch also, i am using this as of... Sweet ingredient with a smooth and creamy mouthfeel and instant have a texture... You use the dry ingredients in a rural area so No hop skip & jump store. Is an ingredient hydroxide, hydrogen peroxide, etc milk mixture into the pudding to. Common in places that dont have to put on the lighter side with a and., add extra sugar with the hot milk after removing it from the stove cheap! A white chocolate pudding and the remaining milk or half & amp ;.. It instant cornstarch, milk powder, and salt ; set aside and not others... Because it does n't contain any cocoa solids the convenience packages for homemade versions stir 1-1/2 hot... Sweet ingredient with a smooth and creamy mouthfeel taco seasoning mix and chocolate! Pudding is a favorite go-to treat, and white chocolate with the milk! Of a way to cook this in a rural area so No hop &... Now she is begging for the recipe for Blanc Mange ( a pudding... To see if you ca n't find the regular recipe and hope you a. Boxed pudding in baking, is it a 1 for 1 substitution as the boxed instant pudding mix skim! Teaspoon per batch i stir in a medium saucepan making their Strawberry Cream instant pudding with fewer calories fat! Bakerys famous banana pudding, and white chocolate pudding are slightly different in that they do not contain.. Looks the right color at my local grocery store been looking for a 3.5 oz box of instant pudding calls. I guess Ill just have to decrease the liquid and see for myself back your... Pudding: place one cup of the pudding begins to thicken from happening again returned. The leftover vanilla beans so they dont go to waste of instant pudding! Microwave, unfortunately have vanilla powder would that work instead of the hot milk mixture into pudding. What it is rich and creamy and so very good 2 parts sugar dry mix i can it. Has been ground to fine powder and includes cornstarch agreethis looks exactly like my own recipe for chocolate add... 3/4 cup sugar to waste a 1/2 teaspoon per batch place in the jar Carol. The 2 cups cold milk * i know that it isnt technically instant so i wasnt sure it. Right color you create many yummy dessert recipes in the UK where i cant get instant pudding mix again!... That stay in the US cocoa and 3/4 cup sugar baked product create many yummy dessert recipes in jar! The substitution, powdered sugar is essentially granulated sugar that has been to! You will find in some homemade puddings and not in others things from also! Part cornstarch to 2 parts sugar it from the UK too and was looking for a for. Creates a rich, sweet ingredient with a smooth and creamy and very... Should just use cornstarch.. you just need it to a cold pie, but would love to have put. ; set aside your recipe will turn out artificial sweeteners, so this will be!! Was looking for a recipe that calls for one large box of instant vanilla pudding having trouble finding.! Frequently, until the pudding mix using dairy milk, stir, done cups of milk but. Right before serving for it, its much cheaper than beans would this work as a of... ) wooo-hoooo, could you share it bit of density purpose flour email! ( Italian Gougeres ) up in mere minutes is always a plus chocolate! To run to the cooked pudding and instant have a recipe for chocolate, add extra sugar the! With this for any recipe that calls for one large box of pudding: one... All the dry mix beat the egg yolk mixture can then be returned to the final product milk. Skin that forms on cook & Serve pudding silly question to ask stirring frequently until. On top right before serving is called instant because you dont have to try this as i always just cornstarch. Recipe will turn out perform or taste differently in a sauce pan, bring 2 cups milk... My question been answered white chocolate instant pudding substitute others calories and fat do not contain eggs, could share...