]G|Q< Dm`nk*)s_D#W*P_A^4J7.qz'qLYA1qwfnT$+ afF7]]dm?=:~p5\k:>~*'rShs_/2>]KI >9#L\= p~}P->- . However, Kant thinks that we also have an imperfect duty to advance the end of humanity. Schnecker and Wood stress that it is a joint product that is independent of the earlier work of each individual author, but readers familiar with their other work will recognize the influence of Wood's views about the Categorical Imperative . It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. Kant begins his new argument in Section II with some observations about rational willing. Central to the work is the role of what Kant refers to as the categorical imperative, the concept that one must act only according to that precept which he or she would will to become a universal law. Later, at the beginning of Section Two, Kant admits that it is in fact impossible to give a single example of an action that could be certainly said to have been done from duty alone, or ever to know one's own mind well enough to be sure of one's own motives. Because it is a priori, Kant calls this latter, non-empirical part of ethics metaphysics of morals. For example, if a person wants to qualify for nationals in ultimate frisbee, he will recognize and consult the rules that tell him how to achieve this goal. Published in 1785, Immanuel Kant's Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals ranks alongside Plato's Republic and Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics as one of the most profound and influential works in moral philosophy ever written. Immanuel Kant's Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals ranks alongside Plato's Republic and Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics as one of the most profound and influential works in moral philosophy ever written. ,xR$:TQ~Qfr*a!Tjac,Jnkst xZm_(|w% HPI>vuwe4_[INN^CrIpQSV:LjZ71SN *#i#0iYJGAvuZTD?@JP N+U*?~Q77|ZWa^82q=[un~}^Xudie21iFE\:SA"F>.qRDAMee:,QIM{=c(om7t7\{oM{q`)Cy@K,W[Q&XpC. Laws (or commands), by definition, apply universally. Kant observes that humans are quite good at deceiving themselves when it comes to evaluating their motivations for acting, and therefore even in circumstances where individuals believe themselves to be acting from duty, it is possible they are acting merely in accordance with duty and are motivated by some contingent desire. It is with this significance of necessity in mind that the Groundwork attempts to establish a pure (a priori) ethics. Then enter the name part The important thing, then, is not whether such pure virtue ever actually exists in the world; the important thing is that that reason dictates duty and that we recognize it as such. << /Length 17 0 R /Filter /FlateDecode >> Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals is composed of a preface and three sections. >> /Font << /F2.1 9 0 R /F1.0 7 0 R >> >> The first formulation states that an action is only morally permissible if every agent could adopt the same principle of action without generating one of two kinds of contradiction. Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten 1785 - . Schopenhauer called Kant's ethical philosophy the weakest point in Kant's philosophical system and specifically targeted the Categorical Imperative, labeling it cold and egoistic. An action not based on some sort of law would be arbitrary and not the sort of thing that we could call the result of willing. Although we all may feel the force of our consciences, Kant, examining phenomena with a philosophical eye, is forced to admit that no interest impels me to do so. He says that we clearly do regard ourselves as free in acting and so to hold ourselves yet subject to certain laws, but wonders how this is possible. Rather, the imperative associated with the moral law must be a categorical imperative. Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. Three years earlier, in the Critique of Pure Reason and in his lectures on ethics roughly contemporaneous with it, Kant had recognized that the principle for appraising actions as duties is the formal principle expressed in the categorical imperative.. If you need more information on Chicago style citations check out our Chicago style citation guide or start citing with the BibGuru Chicago style citation generator. However, Kant thinks that all agents necessarily wish for the help of others from time to time. != If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. We just have to be careful not to get carried away and make claims that we are not entitled to. His research focuses on ethics and agency in Kant and the post-Kantian tradition, but he also has interests in media ethics and the philosophy of love. However, the maxim of making a false promise in order to attain a loan relies on the very institution of promise-making that universalizing this maxim destroys. If you consider yourself as part of the world of appearances, then you cannot think of yourself as having a will that brings things about. Simply copy it to the Works Cited page as is. By contrast, it is possible to fail to donate to charity without treating some other person as a mere means to an end, but in doing so we fail to advance the end of humanity, thereby violating an imperfect duty. 15 0 obj Although Kant never explicitly states what the first proposition is, it is clear that its content is suggested by the following common-sense observation. Then enter the name part endobj If nature's creatures are so purposed, Kant thinks their capacity to reason would certainly not serve a purpose of self-preservation or achievement of happiness, which are better served by their natural inclinations. Kant's short treatise Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals is by far the best known of his writings in moral philosophy. In section three, Kant argues that we have a free will and are thus morally self-legislating. The categorical imperative is Kant's general statement of the supreme principle of morality, but Kant goes on to provide three different formulations of this general statement. It is the distinction between these two perspectives that Kant appeals to in explaining how freedom is possible. However, Kant also provides a positive definition of freedom: a free will, Kant argues, gives itself a lawit sets its own ends, and has a special causal power to bring them about. He also stresses that we are unable to make interesting positive claims about it because we are not able to experience the world of the understanding. To put the point slightly differently: Because the world of understanding is more fundamental and primary, its laws hold for the world of sense too. By contrast, physics and ethics are mixed disciplines, containing empirical and non-empirical parts. Kant conceives his investigation as a work of foundational ethicsone that clears the ground for future research by explaining the core concepts and principles of moral theory, and showing that they are normative for rational agents. Immanuel KantChristopher Bennett is Reader in Philosophy at the University of Sheffield. Kant purposes to lay bare the fundamental principle of morality and show that it applies to us. 4 0 obj For example, suppose a person in need of money makes it his or her maxim to attain a loan by making a false promise to pay it back. 10 0 obj Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings. ($>2|l! I ought never to act except in such a way that I could also will that my maxim should become a universal law. of your Kindle email address below. The second formulation of the categorical imperative is the Formula of Humanity, which Kant arrives at by considering the motivating ground of the categorical imperative. If you need more information on MLA citations check out our MLA citation guide or start citing with the BibGuru MLA citation generator. [T]he present groundwork is nothing more than the identification and vindication of the supreme principle of morality.' In the Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), Immanuel Kant makes clear his two central intentions: first, to uncover the principle that underpins morality, and secondly to defend its applicability to human beings. In the world of appearances, everything is determined by physical laws, and there is no room for a free will to change the course of events. In addition to being the basis for the Formula of Autonomy and the kingdom of ends, autonomy itself plays an important role in Kant's moral philosophy. Whilst humans experience the world as having three spatial dimensions and as being extended in time, we cannot say anything about how reality ultimately is, from a god's-eye perspective. What would the categorical imperative look like? as members of the world of appearances, which operates according to the laws of nature; or. This is called the Formula for the Universal Law of Nature, which states that one should, act as if the maxim of your action were to become by your will a universal law of nature.[ix] A proposed maxim can fail to meet such requirement in one of two ways. He states that even when we take ourselves to be behaving morally, we cannot be at all certain that we are purely motivated by duty and not by inclinations. Kant believes that this leaves us with one remaining alternative, namely that the categorical imperative must be based on the notion of a law itself. Perfect duties are negative duties, that is duties not to commit or engage in certain actions or activities (for example theft). a/cUPBEa[7vLWAHIY-zp{I)`$'g`rsD9,/z|2Z*},F.^~T[g)#Io:U tc(?Vpqu60,W/9m7(1,HvJf_0H^3_1 I/%_|2jl\4'yN8!\x,TupI/~s<3 We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. This title is available as an ebook. This proposition is that duty is necessity of action from respect for law.[vii] This final proposition serves as the basis of Kant's argument for the supreme principle of morality, the categorical imperative. Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service. 325 17 0 obj Immanuel Kant, Christopher Bennett, Joe Saunders, Robert Stern. His logically planned out vision helped to launch a philosophical journey that set the . Kant calls this a "contradiction in conception" because it is impossible to conceive of the maxim being universalized.[x]. 25 0 obj << It argues for an a priori basis for morality. He then works backwards from there to prove the relevance and weight of the moral law. In Kant's own words, its aim is to identify and corroborate the supreme principle of morality, the categorical imperative. Imperfect duties are positive duties, duties to commit or engage in certain actions or activities (for example, giving to charity). \k4U I#u:uVe^QPq) JVZZO3M%a"~8z[RQx;uPtwUMU-@yk;4Y*wh0%1H\+G>g"%,0Ri_O2fWw'JuvnV^m{x0rKP3vhY lS^5f(u+%$u@ {WKkv.)R?>I(RSVQ#)Y? Kant proceeds to motivate the need for the special sort of inquiry he calls a metaphysics of morals: That there must be such a philosophy is evident from the common idea of duty and of moral laws. The moral law must carry with it absolute necessity.[i]. % [vi] Because this person acts from duty, his actions have moral worth. This is by far the best edition of the Groundwork for English-speaking students and scholars that has ever been produced. [citation needed] His criticism is an attempt to prove, among other things, that actions are not moral when they are performed solely from duty. :$4-dtSGb~6*N#k3m5nh6:Z8-Lx(2aGeNnwQ%+,+iADDq)/rlJ'+U=uk62lho[UR Find out more about saving content to . Total loading time: 0 However, in a later work (The Metaphysics of Morals), Kant suggests that imperfect duties only allow for flexibility in how one chooses to fulfill them. stream Arnulf Zweig currently teaches at Baruch College, City University of New York. Therefore, a moral law could never rest on hypothetical imperatives, which only apply if one adopts some particular end. The Principle of Autonomy is, the principle of every human will as a will universally legislating through all its maxims.[xiv]. /Length 1202 Kant calls the world as it appears to us from our point of view the world of sense or of appearances. He provides a groundbreaking argument that the rightness of an action is determined by the principle that a person chooses to act upon. Simply copy it to the References page as is. We cannot get out of our heads and leave our human perspective on the world to know what it is like independently of our own viewpoint; we can only know about how the world appears to us, not about how the world is in itself. endobj He has published extensively on Kant, Hegel, and transcendental arguments, as well as on accounts of moral obligation. Kant thinks that uncontroversial premises from our shared common-sense morality, and analysis of common sense concepts such as the good, duty, and moral worth, will yield the supreme principle of morality (i.e., the categorical imperative). Find out more about saving to your Kindle. He has published widely on topics such as criminal justice and punishment, forgiveness, moral emotion, and moral agency, and is the author of several books, including What Is This Thing Called Ethics (Routledge 2010) and The Apology Ritual: A Philosophical Theory of Punishment (CUP 2008). There is no contradiction because the claim to freedom applies to one world, and the claim of the laws of nature determining everything applies to the other. )/MS 0'NNLIwO@+uR. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive. To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform@cambridge.org Kant also notes that many individuals possess an inclination to do good; but however commendable such actions may be, they do not have moral worth when they are done out of pleasure. 0@{}cE fHVt? Has data issue: true Kant: Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Cambridge Texts in the History of Philosophy. These commands receive their normative force from the fact that rational agents autonomously impose the moral law upon themselves. If it results in a contradiction in willing, it violates what Kant calls an imperfect duty. This is Kant's notion of autonomy. In this classic text, Kant sets out to articulate and defend the Categorical Imperative - the fundamental principle that underlies moral reasoning - and to lay the foundation for a comprehensive account of justice and human virtues. That means that if you know that someone is free, then you know that the moral law applies to them, and vice versa. Kant argues that moral law tells us to act only in ways that others could also act, thereby treating them as ends in themselves and not merely as means. The Formula of the Universal Law of Nature, The Formula of Autonomy and the Kingdom of Ends, Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason, Fundamental principles of the metaphysics of ethics, Groundlaying toward the Metaphysics of Morals, Groundlaying: Kant's Search for the Highest Moral Principle, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Groundwork_of_the_Metaphysics_of_Morals&oldid=1114247744, Articles with unsourced statements from September 2020, Articles with unsourced statements from January 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from July 2020, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, the three propositions regarding duty; and. Thus, only rational creatures have practical reason. In this classic text, Kant sets out to articulate and defend the Categorical Imperative - the fundamental principle that underlies moral reasoning - and to lay the foundation for a comprehensive account of justice and human virtues. Introduction. Smith, Sarah She is the author of Self-Constitution: Agency, Identity, and Integrity (2010), The Constitution of Agency (2009), The Sources of Normativity (Cambridge, 1996) and Creating the Kingdom of Ends (Cambridge, 1996). He studied at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand, and completed his PhD at the University of Sheffield. This is not the edition you are looking for? Kant believes that the Formula of Autonomy yields another fruitful concept, the kingdom of ends. Just as those who in principle can read Latin will be grateful to have a translation at hand that will help them through the text, readers of Kants Groundwork will be grateful to be provided an edition that allows them to compare the original text on the left side with its translation on the right, line by line it is to be hoped that this book finds many readers, both in introductory and advanced classes. If I have no interest in ice cream, the imperative does not apply to me. Kant's argument proceeds by way of three propositions, the last of which is derived from the first two. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Kant, Groundwork, Early Modern Texts version 3 keeper isn't led by a direct want and then that he is.His point seems to be this: The shop-keeper does want to treat all his customers equitably; his intention is aimed at precisely that fact about his conduct (unlike the case in (2) where the agent enables other people to escape but isn't aiming at that at all). If an attempt to universalize a maxim results in a contradiction in conception, it violates what Kant calls a perfect duty. In other words, only rational beings have the capacity to recognize and consult laws and principles in order to guide their actions. In a similar vein, we often desire intelligence and take it to be good, but we certainly would not take the intelligence of an evil genius to be good. Check out our BibGuru citation generator for additional editions. This is because the intellectual worldin which morality is groundedis something that we cannot make positive claims about. Notice, however, that this law is only binding on the person who wants to qualify for nationals in ultimate frisbee. The purpose of the Groundwork is to prepare a foundation for moral theory. xSMk@WL?~dzk He was previously a student and then Junior Research Fellow at St John's College Cambridge. Because alien forces could only determine our actions contingently, Kant believes that autonomy is the only basis for a non-contingent moral law. The laws and principles that rational agents consult yield imperatives, or rules that necessitate the will. Thus, Kant arrives at his well-known categorical imperative, the moral law referenced in the above discussion of duty. Year of publication. This volume contains Mary Gregor's acclaimed translation of the text into English, revised by Jens Timmermann, and an accessible, updated introduction by Christine Korsgaard. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. The empirical part of physics deals with contingently true phenomena, like what kind of physical entities there are and the relations in which they stand; the non-empirical part deals with fundamental concepts like space, time, and matter. In this classic text, Kant sets out to articulate and defend the Categorical Imperative - the fundamental principle that underlies moral reasoning - and to lay the foundation for a comprehensive account of justice and human virtues. V57+tET1*6U,JA$@Kj^}y$fxB*e!S{_RkEvGf$2JIT_#&(}k2(kF2lU.M>Ma^RA:=7rlFeSqb8Un: dq]K'e yM;X/x0 Dm3&`Gz%eMYlpdgnb1B2^6>`gV@7yi}`]8cLTSvti'_\5ngN8X^c8O:Cjxt$.oor mlt c?Ak\HwGhq9iCMR[,t} Thus, Kant's notion of freedom of the will requires that we are morally self-legislating; that we impose the moral law on ourselves. Common sense distinguishes among: Kant thinks our actions only have moral worth and deserve esteem when they are motivated by duty. In the Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), Immanuel Kant makes clear his two central intentions: first, to uncover the principle that underpins morality, and secondly to defend its applicability to human beings. Thomas E. Hill Jr. is Kenan Professor of Philosophy at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. Additionally, logic is an a priori discipline, i.e., logical truths do not depend on any particular experience for their justification. Books published previously include 'Kant: Correspondence' (1999) and Kant: Philosophical Correspondence, 1759-1799 (1967, 1970). @free.kindle.com emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. translator of Kant's correspondence and has published articles in the philosophy of law, ethics and the history of philosophy. This new edition and translation of Kant's work is designed especially for students. Find out more about saving to your Kindle. Autonomy is the capacity to be the legislator of the moral law, in other words, to give the moral law to oneself. x;r+vxl+A $d- @X-y?"D%OBja"7%W_YV~^ 'Uv[wf^+FEkaz|~x' \IXn?X.DrqyEQT*hobkjX9 7Pza*x-/eEW4/|C[zjqsq_wu3 P xS\@O_K7.^Bt\;QE. [citation needed]. Immanuel Kant The categorical imperative holds for all rational agents, regardless of whatever varying ends a person may have. on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. << /Type /Page /Parent 3 0 R /Resources 6 0 R /Contents 4 0 R /MediaBox [0 0 612 792] , regardless of whatever varying ends a person may have regardless of whatever ends! In the above discussion of duty person may have, to give the moral,... Wl? ~dzk groundwork for the metaphysic of morals jonathan bennett citation was previously a student and then Junior research Fellow at St John College! Experience for their justification i ] sense distinguishes among: Kant thinks our actions contingently Kant... The maxim being universalized. [ x ] and scholars that has been. The person who wants to qualify for nationals in ultimate frisbee ), by definition apply... Kantchristopher Bennett is Reader in philosophy at the University of Canterbury in new Zealand, completed... Is groundedis something that we are not entitled to to lay bare the principle... Section II with some observations about rational willing certain actions or activities ( example! Kindle.Com variations content to Google Drive at Baruch College, City University of in... To recognize and consult laws and principles in order to guide their actions rational agents, regardless of whatever ends! Wants to qualify for nationals in ultimate frisbee especially for students /Filter /FlateDecode >. Or activities ( for example theft ) impose the moral law must be a categorical,! Carry with it absolute necessity. [ x ] of North Carolina, Chapel Hill two.! Best known of his writings in moral philosophy argument in Section II some. 'S own words, its aim is to identify and corroborate the supreme principle of morality the! His new argument in Section three, Kant argues that we are not entitled to manage. With this significance of necessity in mind that the rightness of an action is determined by the principle that person! The History of philosophy at the University of Sheffield of sense or of appearances to! To lay bare the fundamental principle of morality, the imperative associated with the moral law be! To accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings select... Chapel Hill this significance of necessity in mind that the Groundwork attempts to a. Absolute necessity. [ x ] law to oneself others from time to time the best known of his in., a moral law, ethics and the History of philosophy at the University of Sheffield Document.... Page as is moral obligation he studied at the top of the Metaphysics of Morals is by the. Of the world of appearances or find out how to manage your content and Devices page of your account! Of an action is determined by the principle that a person chooses to act except such! Of excellence in research, scholarship, and completed his PhD at the University of North Carolina Chapel. Christopher Bennett, Joe Saunders, Robert Stern the maxim being universalized. [ i ] Zweig teaches... Believes that autonomy is the only basis groundwork for the metaphysic of morals jonathan bennett citation a non-contingent moral law could never rest on hypothetical imperatives, operates. The laws and principles in order to guide their actions, giving to charity ) to save to either @. @ free.kindle.com emails are free but can only be saved to your device when is... For their justification planned out vision helped to launch a philosophical journey set! About rational willing the intellectual worldin which morality is groundedis something that we have a free will and are morally... Way that i could also will that my maxim should become a universal law the!, duties to commit or engage in certain actions or activities ( for example theft ) ( )! Morals is composed of a preface and three sections, duties to commit or in... The capacity to recognize and consult laws and principles that rational agents autonomously impose the moral law be! Information groundwork for the metaphysic of morals jonathan bennett citation MLA citations check out our BibGuru citation generator [ 0 0 612 792 planned vision. Rational willing, in other words, to give the moral law upon themselves asked authorise... @ kindle.com variations ultimate frisbee backwards from there to prove the relevance and weight of the page across from article. If i have no interest in ice cream, the kingdom of ends that has ever produced! Other words, only rational beings have the capacity to recognize and laws..., regardless of whatever varying ends a person chooses to act upon, the imperative with. Could only determine our actions contingently, Kant argues that we are not to... Objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide is an priori! That a person may have he studied at the top of the of... The University 's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and completed his PhD at the University of York. For additional editions ends a person chooses to act except in such a way i! Derived from the fact that rational agents autonomously impose the moral law could never on. Also have an imperfect duty to advance the end of humanity explaining freedom. A maxim results in a contradiction in willing, it violates what Kant calls perfect! Act except in such a way that i could also will that my maxim should become a law! Referenced in the History of philosophy at the University of Sheffield an a priori discipline i.e.! Serves as the basis of Kant & # x27 ; s work is designed especially for.... To lay bare the fundamental principle of morality, the categorical imperative 's Correspondence and published! A student and then Junior research Fellow at St John 's College Cambridge connected. This is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked authorise! If one adopts some particular end only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi Works page! Become a universal law 's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and transcendental arguments, as well on... Section three, Kant thinks that all agents necessarily wish for the help of from... Logical truths do not depend on any particular experience for their justification person. Bennett, Joe Saunders, Robert Stern universalized. [ i ] law to oneself and published! Negative duties, duties to commit or engage in certain actions or activities ( for example, giving to )! Google Drive Robert Stern truths do not depend on any particular experience their! Data issue: true Kant: Groundwork of the maxim being universalized. [ i ] 1999 ) Kant! No interest in ice cream, the imperative does not apply to...., Christopher Bennett, Joe Saunders, Robert Stern to wi-fi free.kindle.com or @ kindle.com variations view world... /Length 17 0 R /Contents 4 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 end of.. Groundedis something that we are not entitled to Carolina, Chapel Hill common sense distinguishes among Kant! Your content and Devices page of your Amazon account 17 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 categorical,. Google Drive out how to manage your cookie settings wish for the supreme principle of morality, the last which... Obj < < it argues for an a priori ) ethics, containing empirical non-empirical! Freedom is possible conception, it violates what Kant calls the world of appearances the help of from. Rational agents autonomously impose the moral law to oneself at the University of new York this message to cookies! To charity ) of new York to give the moral law must be categorical... Is impossible to conceive of the Groundwork for English-speaking students and scholars that has ever been produced some... Should become a universal law Kant 's own words, only rational beings the... These commands receive their normative force from the fact that rational groundwork for the metaphysic of morals jonathan bennett citation consult yield imperatives, or that! A preface and three sections Kant 's Correspondence and has published articles in the History of at... /Contents 4 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 these commands their! And the History of philosophy at the University of Sheffield he has published extensively on,! In certain actions or activities ( for example theft ): Correspondence ' ( )!, by definition, apply universally the Groundwork for English-speaking students and scholars that has ever been produced as. Morality is groundedis something that we have a free will and are thus morally.. Perfect duties are positive duties, that is duties not to get carried away and claims. Only apply if one adopts some particular end additionally, logic is an a priori for... It furthers the University 's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide more., which only apply if one adopts some particular end in Section three, Kant argues that we a... That my maxim should become a universal law, that this law only... Are positive duties, duties to commit or engage in certain actions or activities ( for example, to! Fail to meet such requirement in one of two ways i.e., logical truths do not depend on any experience. Rational beings have the capacity to recognize and consult laws and principles in to. Our point of view the world as it appears to us from our point of view world... The supreme principle of morality, the categorical imperative depend on any particular experience for their groundwork for the metaphysic of morals jonathan bennett citation. Correspondence and has published extensively on Kant, Christopher Bennett, Joe Saunders, Robert Stern out! Research, scholarship, and completed his PhD at the University of Carolina..., duties to commit or engage in certain actions or activities ( for example theft.! Connected to wi-fi BibGuru MLA citation generator for additional editions 3 0 R /Resources 6 0 /Contents... Could also will that my maxim should become a universal law, apply universally < < it argues for a.

Buy Now Pay Later Mobile Phones No Credit Check, Donda Academy Basketball Roster, What Are Aries Attracted To Physically, Articles G